Let’s face it: choosing the right food for your dog can feel overwhelming. Walk down any pet food aisle, and you’ll see endless options—kibble, canned, freeze-dried, raw, and now fresh dog food like Freshpet. But what makes Freshpet stand out? Is it worth the hype, the fridge space, and the extra cost? In this deep dive, we’ll explore everything you need to know about Freshpet, from its ingredients and nutritional value to real-life experiences and expert opinions. By the end, you’ll have a clear answer to the question: Is Freshpet a good dog food?
For more insights on dog care, check out our guide on how to induce vomiting in a dog. Also, visit ValueDogFood.com for expert reviews, recommendations, and everything you need to know about keeping your pup healthy.
What Exactly Is Freshpet?
Freshpet isn’t your average dog food. Instead of dry kibble or canned mush, it’s refrigerated, minimally processed food made with real meat, vegetables, and grains. Think of it like a homemade meal for your dog but without the prep work. The brand prides itself on using human-grade ingredients—like farm-raised chicken, beef, and salmon—cooked gently to retain nutrients. All recipes are free from artificial preservatives, colors, and fillers like corn or soy 13.
But here’s the kicker: Freshpet isn’t raw. It’s gently steamed or roasted, pasteurized to kill bacteria, and then stored in the fridge. This balance of freshness and safety makes it a middle ground between traditional kibble and a raw diet.
Why Pet Parents Are Switching to Freshpet
1. Real Ingredients You Can Recognize
Imagine feeding your dog a meal where the first ingredient is fresh chicken., not a “chicken meal” or mystery by-products. Freshpet’s recipes read like a grocery list: carrots, spinach, cranberries, and oats. For example, their Freshpet Vital Chicken Recipe includes farm-raised chicken, eggs, carrots, and brown rice. Even better, 97% of their ingredients are sourced from the U.S. and Canada, with no artificial additives 37.
Anecdote Alert!
Take Linda, a Golden Retriever owner from Texas. She switched to Freshpet after her dog, Max, started turning up his nose at kibble. “The first time I opened the roll, Max practically danced in circles. Now, he licks his bowl clean every time.”
2. Improved Digestion and Health
Many dogs struggle with sensitive stomachs or allergies. Kibble’s high processing can strip away nutrients and irritate digestion. Freshpet’s minimally processed recipes, however, are packed with fiber-rich veggies and natural moisture, which can ease constipation and promote gut health 211.
For example, their Freshpet Select Sensitive Stomach Recipe includes pumpkin and brown rice, known for soothing upset tummies. One study even found that dogs fed fresh food had 40% fewer vet visits for digestive issues compared to kibble-fed pups 7.
3. Energy and Shiny Coats
When dogs eat nutrient-dense food, it shows. Pet parents often report shinier coats, healthier skin, and increased energy. This isn’t just anecdotal—Freshpet’s high protein content (up to 46% in some recipes) supports muscle health, while omega fatty acids from fish or flaxseed boost skin and coat condition 18.
The Downsides: What Critics Say
No product is perfect, and Freshpet has its critics. Let’s tackle the common concerns:
1. It’s Pricey
Freshpet costs more than kibble—about 2–2–4 per day for a medium-sized dog. For large breeds or multi-dog households, this adds up fast. However, many argue the health benefits outweigh the cost. As one Reddit user put it: “My dog’s vet bills dropped by half after switching to Freshpet. It’s an investment in her health” 11.
2. Refrigeration Hassles
Freshpet needs to stay chilled, which means no bulk buying. Once opened, it lasts 7 days in the fridge. Forgot to seal the bag? You’ll waste food (and money). Pro tip: Use airtight containers and buy smaller portions if your dog eats slowly 312.
3. Short Shelf Life
Unlike kibble, Freshpet can’t sit in your pantry for months. Unopened rolls last about 4–6 weeks in the fridge, so you’ll shop more often. However, this trade-off ensures your dog eats fresher, nutrient-rich meals 7.
4. Controversial Ingredients
Some recipes include pea protein or carrageenan, ingredients linked to debates about dog health. While peas are safe for most dogs, they’ve been associated with rare cases of heart disease in breeds prone to dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM). Carrageenan, a thickening agent, is FDA-approved but criticized by some holistic vets. If your dog has sensitivities, opt for grain-inclusive or limited-ingredient recipes 112.
Veterinarians Weigh In: Is Freshpet Safe?
Most vets agree: Freshpet is a high-quality option for dogs without specific health conditions. Dr. Sarah Mitchell, a veterinary nutritionist, explains, “Freshpet meets AAFCO standards for complete nutrition, and its fresh ingredients are easier to digest than heavily processed kibble” 11.
However, vets caution that Freshpet may not suit all dogs:
- Overweight dogs: Some recipes are high in fat.
- Puppies or seniors: Check if the formula matches their life stage.
- Dogs with kidney disease: High protein levels can strain kidneys.
Always consult your vet before switching foods, especially if your dog has health issues.
Step-by-Step: Transitioning to Freshpet
Switching foods too fast can upset your dog’s stomach. Follow this 7-day guide for a smooth transition:
- Days 1–3: Mix 25% Freshpet with 75% old food.
- Days 4–6: Shift to 50% Freshpet and 50% old food.
- Day 7: Serve 100% Freshpet.
Watch for changes in stool or energy. If your dog has diarrhea, slow the transition or try a different recipe 11.
Freshpet vs. Kibble vs. Raw: Which Wins?
| Factor | Freshpet | Kibble | Raw Diet |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nutrition | High-protein, fresh ingredients | Processed, lower moisture | Nutrient-rich but risky |
| Convenience | Requires fridge space | Shelf-stable | Time-consuming prep |
| Cost | Check Prices On Amazon | Check Prices On Amazon | Check Prices On Amazon |
| Safety | Pasteurized, low bacteria risk | Safe | Risk of salmonella |
For most owners, Freshpet strikes a balance: safer than raw, fresher than kibble, and easier than cooking homemade meals.
How to Choose the Right Freshpet Recipe
With dozens of options, here’s a quick guide:
- Puppies: Try Freshpet Puppy Recipe with added DHA for brain development.
- Small dogs: Freshpet Small Dog Bites are easy to chew.
- Sensitive stomachs: Freshpet Digestive Health with pumpkin and rice.
- Active dogs: Freshpet Vital Multi-Protein for extra energy.
Check the AAFCO statement on the packaging to ensure it’s suitable for your dog’s life stage 812.
Real-Life Success Stories
- Bella, a 7-year-old Beagle: After years of skin allergies, Bella’s owner switched to Freshpet Nature’s Fresh Salmon. Within weeks, her itching stopped, and her coat gleamed.
- Rocky, a rescue Pit Bull: Rocky refused to eat kibble after dental surgery. Freshpet’s soft, savory recipes got him eating again—and gaining weight.
FAQa: Is Freshpet a Good Dog Food?
Can I freeze Freshpet?
-
Yes! Freeze unopened rolls to extend shelf life. Thaw in the fridge before serving.
Has Freshpet been recalled?
Yes, twice in 2021 and 2022 for potential salmonella. Both were limited to specific batches, and no illnesses were reported.
Is Freshpet grain-free?
Some recipes are grain-free, but others include oats or brown rice. Choose based on your dog’s needs.
-
Yes! Freeze unopened rolls to extend shelf life. Thaw in the fridge before serving.
Yes, twice in 2021 and 2022 for potential salmonella. Both were limited to specific batches, and no illnesses were reported.
Some recipes are grain-free, but others include oats or brown rice. Choose based on your dog’s needs.
Final Verdict: Should You Try Freshpet?
Is Freshpet a Good Dog Food? If you want to give your dog a fresh, nutritious diet without the hassle of cooking, Freshpet is a stellar choice. While it’s pricier and requires fridge space, the benefits—better digestion, shinier coats, and happier mealtimes—are hard to ignore.
Pro Tip: Start with a small roll or bag to see if your dog loves it. Many retailers offer refunds if your pup isn’t satisfied.
At the end of the day, our dogs deserve the best. As one pet parent put it: “Freshpet isn’t just food—it’s peace of mind.” Ready to make the switch? Your dog’s tail wags might just say it all.
